Compare / PayHOA
PayHOA runs the books. We run the work.
We took a full PayHOA trial before writing this, clicked through every section, and kept the notes. Here is the honest version: they are a payments and accounting company, we are a maintenance and communication company, and the right answer depends on which problem is actually keeping your board up.
The short version
PayHOA is built around money moving: online dues, double-entry accounting, an accounts-payable inbox that cuts real checks, and an embedded bank account with spend cards. neighborPOP is built around work getting done: the request a neighbor sends, the vendor who fixes it, the board that has to approve the spend, and the email that tells everyone what happened. Both collect dues online. Only one of us will also write your board meeting agenda, and only one of them will reconcile your bank statement.
When you should pick PayHOA
Written by us, on our own site, because a comparison that never concedes anything is an advertisement.
- You want full double-entry accounting inside the same tool: a balance sheet, a general ledger, bank reconciliation, and a chart of accounts. We do not build that, on purpose, and hand a clean export to QuickBooks or your bookkeeper instead.
- You want the software to physically mail things: paper invoices, paper violation notices, paper ballots. They run a mail room; we give you a print button.
- You want the platform to hold your money, issue spend cards, and pay vendors by check on your behalf.
- Your community is under about 50 homes and price is the deciding factor. At that size their published rate is lower than our flat $79.
- You need formal elections with anonymous ballots and tabulation. We deliberately ship the advisory tier: polls and surveys, not elections.
Side by side
| neighborPOP | PayHOA | |
|---|---|---|
| What you pay each month | $79 flat, any size community | Scales with homes: $54 at 25 homes, $109 at 100, $186 at 200, $275 at 500 |
| Free trial | 60 days, no card | 30 days, no card |
| Work order lifecycle | Full: intake, triage, approval, vendor, cost, close, with photos and an event log on every job | A maintenance request form and a list of submissions |
| Vendors | Magic links: a vendor opens the job, adds photos, marks it done, with no account | Vendor records for paying bills |
| Board approvals | Dollar threshold, chair or N-of-board, decided from an email link | Not a built-in workflow |
| AI in the workflow | Reads the inbound email, drafts the work order, drafts the notice letter, writes the board packet, and never sends anything itself | A chatbot tab inside the website builder |
| Recurring maintenance | Schedules that open real work orders inside their lead window | Not present |
| Online dues | Bank transfer or card, no resident account, money settles to the HOA's own bank | Yes, plus autopay and offline payment recording |
| Accounting | Budget vs actual, per-home statements, CSV exports; your books stay in QuickBooks | Full double-entry: balance sheet, general ledger, bank rec, 1099s |
| Paying vendors | We track the bill and what you paid; you pay from your own bank | They can cut and mail the check |
| Physical mail | Print buttons for notices, statements, and flyers | A mail room that posts it for you, per piece |
| Do residents need accounts? | Never. Report, pay, or reserve from a link | Yes, with activation emails to chase |
| Board packet | AI drafts the agenda and the opening remarks from this month's real activity | Report packets: a bundle of financial PDFs run together |
| Elections | Advisory polls and surveys only | Anonymous ballots with tabulation, paper option |
| Text messages and robocalls | Not built | Both |
Checked August 2026. Green marks the stronger side of each row, in both directions.
The question that actually decides it
Ask your board what went wrong last year. If the answers are about money you could not account for, a treasurer drowning in reconciliation, or an audit that went badly, buy the accounting product. If the answers are about a roof leak nobody followed up on, three neighbors who never heard back, a vendor who was never paid because the invoice was in somebody's personal inbox, or a decision the board made twice because nobody wrote it down, that is the problem we built for. Most small self-managed communities have the second problem and buy software for the first, which is why so many boards own a tool nobody opens.
What the flat price really changes
Per-door pricing is not just a number, it is a slow tax on growth and a reason to be careful about what you record. Our rate is $79 a month whether you have 30 homes or 250, and it includes every feature we ship, now and later. There are no per-user seats, so adding a fifth board member or a committee volunteer costs nothing, and no per-door meter, so a community that annexes a section does not get a bigger bill. Founding communities lock $59 for life. Be fair about the comparison though: below roughly 50 homes their published rate is lower than ours, and if price is the whole decision, that is your answer.
Where your money sits
PayHOA offers an embedded bank account with a balance, spend cards, and bill payment. That is genuinely useful, and it is also the part we will never build. When a resident pays dues through neighborPOP, the money settles straight into the association's own bank account through the association's own merchant account. We never hold it, never route it, and take no cut of any payment. The processing fee is shown to the resident before they choose how to pay, and the association receives the full dues amount. That is a smaller product and a much smaller thing to worry about at a board meeting.
How we checked this
We ran a full PayHOA trial in August 2026 and clicked through every section of the product, not just the marketing site. Prices come from their own published pricing page as of the same month, using their standard monthly rates rather than the annual-discount rates, because that is what a community that pays monthly actually pays. Software changes; if something here is out of date, tell us and we will correct it rather than leave it up.
Questions boards ask
Can we run both?
Boards do. The common shape is accounting in one place and operations in the other, with dues collected wherever the treasurer prefers. It is two bills, so most communities eventually pick, but nothing stops you from running both while you decide.
Can we move our data over?
Yes. Bring a member roster as a CSV, a budget as a spreadsheet, and a management-company statement as a PDF, and the import wizard reads all three, checks its own reading against the totals printed on your document, and shows you exactly what will change before anything saves.
Do you collect dues too?
Yes. One invoice per home, residents pay by bank transfer or card with no account to create, autopay is available, and the treasurer can record a check in two clicks. The money settles to the association's own bank.
Why no accounting?
Because doing it badly is worse than not doing it, and doing it well means becoming an accounting company. Your books stay where your bookkeeper already works, and we export clean CSVs into them. We would rather be the best operations product for small HOAs than the fifth-best accounting one.
What if we have 400 homes?
The price is still $79. The product is built and tested for communities under about 250 homes, so tell us your size before you commit and we will be straight with you about whether it fits.
See it with your community's name on it
60 days free, no credit card, and we do the setup with you.
See the live demo Talk to us